Utah Business Broker or M&A Advisor: Which One Do You Need?
Utah owners researching a sale run into two different kinds of firm, often without realizing they are different. Picking the wrong one is one of the more expensive mistakes available at this size.
What a business broker does
A business broker typically lists a company publicly, on marketplaces and their own site, and works with individual buyers who respond. The model is volume and visibility. Financing is usually SBA, and the buyer is often someone leaving corporate life to own a business.
This is a legitimate and useful model. For a restaurant, a retail shop, a small service business, or an owner-operated company worth under roughly one to two million dollars, a broker will usually serve you faster and at lower cost than anyone else.
What a sell-side M&A advisor does
An advisor runs a confidential, targeted process. Your company is not listed publicly anywhere. A screened buyer list gets built deliberately, buyers sign NDAs and get qualified before they learn your name, and several parties are driven to a common timeline so their offers compete.
The advisor also does work a broker typically does not: normalizing three years of earnings and documenting every add-back, building a confidential information memorandum, managing diligence and the buyer's lender, and negotiating structure and terms rather than just price.
Which one fits your company
The honest dividing line is roughly where the buyer pool changes.
Below about one to two million dollars in value, your likely buyer is an individual. Public listing reaches them efficiently, and a broker is the right call.
Above that, your likely buyers include strategic acquirers and private equity platforms who will never browse a marketplace listing. Reaching them requires targeted outreach. Meanwhile, a public listing actively works against you: it tells your market you are for sale and attracts the least sophisticated end of the buyer pool.
There is also a practical test. If your company has management depth, contracted or recurring revenue, or would interest a competitor or a consolidator, you are in advisory territory regardless of size.
What each costs
Brokers typically charge a commission on the sale, often around ten percent at Main Street size, sometimes with a listing or marketing fee. Sell-side advisors in the lower middle market generally charge a success fee that scales down as transaction size goes up, sometimes with an engagement fee credited against it at closing.
Fee percentage is the wrong thing to optimize. At this size the difference between a competitive process and a single-buyer negotiation is routinely seven figures. The difference between a six and an eight percent fee is not.
A note specific to Utah
Utah has plenty of capable business brokers, and if you are Main Street you should use one. What Utah has less of is firms running genuinely competitive, confidential sell-side processes for companies in the one to thirty million range, and reaching buyers well outside the state to do it.
Ask any firm you interview two questions. Do you take buy-side mandates? And will my company be listed publicly? The answers tell you which kind of firm you are talking to.
Aesir Business Advisors works exclusively on the sell side and never lists client companies publicly. For Main Street businesses below our range, we refer owners to a brokerage rather than take an engagement we cannot serve well.
Common questions
What is the difference between a business broker and an M&A advisor?
A broker typically lists a company publicly and works with individual buyers who respond. An advisor runs a confidential targeted process, builds a screened buyer list, and drives multiple qualified parties to a common timeline.
Which do I need for my business?
Below roughly one to two million dollars in value your likely buyer is an individual, and a broker reaches them efficiently. Above that, your likely buyers include strategics and private equity who will never browse a listing.
What should I ask before hiring either?
Do you take buy-side mandates, and will my company be listed publicly. The answers tell you which kind of firm you are talking to.
Comments